Site Logo

Life of an Architect

  • Podcast
  • about me
  • Questions / Contact
  • F. A. Q.
  • Do you want to be an Architect?
  • Architecture Books+
You are here: Home / Construction / Fireplace Mantle – Nice and Simple

Fireplace Mantle – Nice and Simple

September 13, 2016 by Bob Borson 25 Comments

Let’s pretend for a moment that you are designing a modern style house and you are in the middle of trying to figure out how your fireplace mantle will look. This exact scenario probably happens every single day somewhere on the planet. I am here to tell you that the following is not what you should be considering:

poorly scaled fireplace mantle

There are a lot of things about this mantel that bothers me – but since I think I’m a nice guy, I am going to preface my comments by saying that the person who put this mantel together is probably a nice and talented person … but this mantel is not for me.

So. Much. Going. On!!

In addition to asking you to ignore the numbers in that picture (I didn’t create them), I’m going to ask you to ignore the fact that this isn’t even a fireplace.

Simply put, the scale and proportion of this entire fireplace surround and mantel are wrong, and the style is something I really don’t care for. Everything about this fireplace, all the visual clues (except the brick and the surrounding furniture) would lead me to believe that this non-fireplace is humongous. I will confess how I found this image: I went to Google and typed in “Fireplace Mantel DIY” … of course it’s a DIY mantelpiece. You can probably figure out for yourselves where I found the image.

So let’s move on to the mantel surround that was just installed at one of my projects – it’s got some size and scale-defying trickery going on as well – hopefully, the good kind.

Millwork Wall with Ryan

This fireplace is an Isokern ‘Magnum’ fireplace from Earthcore. We use a lot of these types of fireplaces because they come as a kit of parts and we have some flexibility over the finished size/opening. Am I really so fussy that I need custom sized fireplaces? Yeah, I kinda am that fussy.

I am including the picture above because it has a scale figure in it … Ryan. I don’t actually know how tall Ryan is, but I am going to put him in the 5′-10″ range when he stands up straight. Rather than try and run down all the particular dimensions of this room and that fireplace, I am going to include an elevation drawing of this exact view, complete with dimensions down below.

fireplace surround drawings from Dallas Architect Bob Borson

Here it is [click to enlarge]. The ceilings in this main living room are 12′-0″ and the walnut paneled portion of the wall where the fireplace is located is 15′-4″ across. This is a big wall and in order for our fireplace and mantel to be simple AND have a role of prominence on the wall, the scale was really important. Another constraint we were working around was the maximum width of walnut paneling that is on the wall with the fireplace.

fireplace surround enlarged stone profile

This is an enlarged look at the stone profile that surrounds the fireplace. As you can see, there is a slight taper to the stone – it’s not much, it goes from 4″ down to 3″ across the 18″ width of the face of the stone. We have also inset a complimentary stone within the mantle surround to help with the scale.

main living room-mantle installation

So here’s a look at the newly installed fireplace with the walnut panels finished and the stone mantel set in place. The first thing I notice about this wall is that the scale of the fireplace, at 6′-2″ tall, doesn’t look as tall as it really is.

main living room-mantle installation

Let’s do an experiment, if it isn’t already too late. Try and imagine just how tall someone standing next to that fireplace who is 5′-10″ tall. Got it in you mind?

Okay … scroll down

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

main living room fireplace surround with scale figure

How did you do? At 5′-10″, that scale figure represents the height of the average American male (my apologies to other countries that aren’t where this project is located). If you are someone who designs for a living and is used to thinking about scale and proportion, I’d guess you did alright. When I brought the office by the job site for a field trip, pretty much everyone was surprised by just how big that fireplace and surround was – even when they were standing in this room while moving from one end towards the fireplace. It wasn’t until they were literally standing right next to the fireplace did the actual height really come across.

I found that immensely rewarding.

main living room fireplace-surround-overview - putting up protection

Here is a look at the mantle from the side.

As a brief anecdote – the stone fabricator was worried that the chamfered profile, coupled with the length of the top piece, would be prone to breaking during fabrication. We did end up making some slight tweaks, (we reduced the amount of the chamfer) but I really thought this particular design should stay in place. It had the right balance of scale and simplicity but delivered the impact I thought this main wall required.

main living room fireplace - surround mitred corners

And finally, a close-up look at the mitered corners of both the leuders limestone and the interior gray 3cm Basaltina slab. It’s hard to see in this picture, but if you look really closely, you can tell it’s there.

The contractor hasn’t mortared the leuders yet in case you were wondering … the gaps are not part of the design. I’ve said it before, but it bears repeating: Size, scale, and proportion are where a good architect makes their living. There are all sorts of devices that have been developed to help designers determine how best to guide them in their creations … the Golden Section, the Modular, the Canons of Proportion, on and on. I typically don’t use any of these devices choosing instead to rely on what looks right to me. People wonder why I sketch as much as I do when I am designing, arguing that working in Revit or AutoCAD is soooooo much faster. I don’t do it for speed, I sketch because it helps me work through scale and proportion.

Cheers,

Bob-AIA scale figure

even better stuff from Life of an Architect

Words that Architects use: Architect Bingo Card #3
KHouse Modern Progress Update 05
Putting in the Work
New Roads for Architectural Engagement
Facebook Fan Pages
For Architects, Patience is Definitely a Virtue
You have something gross on your face
Residential Architecture 101: Shutters
Natural Light - Clean Aesthetics
Design Talk - The Glamorous World of Blogging

Share this:

  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window)
  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window)
  • Click to print (Opens in new window)

Filed Under: Construction, Design, Materials and Products, Modern House Tagged With: Construction Observation, Construction Process, design, fireplace, Modern Architecture, modern house

Search Life of an Architect

Trending on Life of an Architect

Architectural Graphics 101 - Symbols
Architectural Graphics 101: Finish Schedules
Architectural Graphics 101 - Window Schedules
Architectural Graphics 101 - Wall Types
Architectural Graphics 101: Cover Sheet
Architectural Graphics 101 - Title Blocks
Graphic Standards
Graphic Standards for Architectural Cabinetry
Architectural Graphics 101 - Line Weight
Steel Stair Panels - Guardrails and Handrails

Subscribe to Podcast

Apple PodcastsGoogle PodcastsSpotifyAndroidiHeartRadioby EmailTuneInRSS

Subscribe to our mailing list

* indicates required

Apparel for Architects

T-Shirts for Architects - Bob Borson

Support for Advice or Guidance

Thanks!
Other Amount:
Project Reference or Support for Questions Answered:

My “Serious” Disclaimer

The complimentary advice provided on ‘Life of an Architect’ is based on an abbreviated examination of the minimal facts given, not the typical extensive (and sometimes exhaustive) analysis I conduct when working with my clients. Therefore, anything you read on this site is not a substitute for actually working with me. Following my casual advice is at your own peril … if you want my undivided attention, I would recommend hiring me. Cheers.

Pages

  • Comment Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Architecture Books+
  • about me
  • Questions?
  • F. A. Q.
  • Do you want to be an Architect?
  • Podcast

Life of an Architect | Bob Borson

  • View lifeofanarchitect’s profile on Facebook
  • View bobborson’s profile on Twitter
  • View bobborson’s profile on Instagram
  • View bborson’s profile on LinkedIn

Archives of Awesomeness

Copyright © 2023 Life of an Architect

 

Loading Comments...