Site Logo

Life of an Architect

  • Podcast
  • about me
  • Questions / Contact
  • F. A. Q.
  • Do you want to be an Architect?
  • Architecture Books+
You are here: Home / Life in General / What is Art?

What is Art?

August 17, 2010 by Bob Borson 42 Comments

Art can truly be judged by you, the individual, as far as you yourself are concerned, by only one measure. It is not a static but an energy measure. Do not ask what the art is or ought to be, for this is debatable and will inevitably lead to endless argument. Ask only what is does – not what it does to somebody else, for this again is only hearsay, but what it does to you. No matter how good a painting may be by any and all theoretical esthetic standards, if it does not do something special to you, Mr. John Doe, then it means about as much to you as a rumor of a love affair on Mars heard in a convention of Psychologists. –

Norwood MacGilvary in the article ‘Art and John Doe’, originally published in Pittsburgh Architectural Club’s ‘The Charette’ with excerpt’s reprinted in The Architectural Forum, May 1939

Caravaggio – Supper at Emmaus

The quote from above threw a log on a fire that has been burning in my head for years (despite the apparent lack of fuel, but on the other hand, lots of space). It’s a straight-forward question and one that almost everyone disagrees with me on…


Can architecture be considered art?

Walter de Maria – ‘The Lightning Field’

First off, let me say that architects are not artists, at least not in the traditional meaning of the word. Architects can be artistic but what we make has to conform to standards and measures established by regulatory entities and it has to be evaluated in its ability to perform a specific job. The reason why architects have to be licensed to practice architecture is because we are legally held responsible in that our work is to ensure the health, safety, and welfare of the general public. The title of ‘artist’ carries no similar amount of responsibility to the public at large. As a result, the work architects do can look great and have sculptural qualities but it transcends the label that defines art. Conversely, anything can be artful or artistic but that does not make it art either. Case in point: Seen a Jiffy Lube lately? Its scope may be defined by the requirements of protecting the health, safety, and welfare of the general public but I feel fairly protected from ridicule in that they have never been considered the fruit of an artistic endeavor.

I know that I may have a fairly narrow definition of what is or isn’t art so I asked a bunch of people to tell me what their favorite piece of art was. I didn’t ask for their favorite painting or sculpture intentionally; this was part of my study – what do other people think of when asked to define art. What you see here in this post are some of the responses.

Lyonel Feininger- ‘The Green Bridge II’

Almost everyone who added some text to their submission spoke to how their selection made them feel – which at worst is an ethereal quality that can only be described between people and never physically shared. I’m okay with that because I think art is a personal experience and since I have matured (debatable), I am not heavily influenced in what I like by the opinions of others – only I can determine if I like something or not. I believe that for art to actually be art, it has to accomplish a few things – the least of which is to demonstrate craft and skill in its creation. If I look at something and the first thought that comes to my mind is “I could make that” … that is an ‘X’ … in a bad way. I like my art to be “professional” because, between me and my daughter, I am up to my ears in amateur art. I want my art to represent skill acquired by practice, experience, observation, consideration, and study. I don’t necessarily need it to mean anything because that’s what I bring to the mix.

St Peters Bascillica

 

Picasso – Guernica

 

Annora Spence – ‘Musician and Cat’

Some people might find this hard to believe but I hate watching the local news. I seek my news out through broader channels because the local stuff tends to focus only on the sensational. There is so much bad in this world, I don’t need to invite it into my house. The painting above – ‘Musician and Cat’ – that one’s mine and so is the Caravaggio. I actually have the ‘Musician and Cat’ in my house and I flew to London to get it (that is a great story that I will share if I ever meet you). I look at it and it makes me happy and honestly … I need all of that kind of art I can get.

Michelangelo Buonarroti – ‘The Awakening Slave’

 

Bilbao Guggenheim Museum

The Guggenheim Museum in Bilbao is about as close to sculpture as a building can be – but to me, it’s not art. It’s a fantastic building but there are other things in play that allow me to judge this place. There was great artistic skill needed to create a building and space such as this, but it took an army of people to execute the design – not just one person. That is another distinction that separates art from the artistic – singular vision along with the individual message from the creator. I still don’t think I’ve ever heard an artist explain their creation with “because I thought it would look good”. Of course, they thought it would look good but there’s a meaning somewhere even if they never explain it to anyone – which is okay because you don’t have to know why a thing is the way it is order to like it … but it helps.

Mark Rothko – ‘No. 10’

 

Keller Freres – ‘Wine or water pitcher’

 

Greene & Greene – ‘The Blacker House’

 

Salvador Dali – ‘Christ of St. John of the Cross’

 

Claes Oldenburg – ‘Split Button’

 

Picasso –

I would like to thank some of my friends who took the time and responded with their favorite piece of art (or at least one they liked enough to tell me). If you sent me a suggestion and I didn’t use it, I apologize, I was hoping for 10 suggestions and I received about 30 (surprisingly, there was not one repeat in the entire bunch).

You may or may not agree with me, that’s okay, that’s actually important. This turned out to be a difficult post for me to write because some sort of back and forth dialog is needed to allow this currently one-sided conversation to go somewhere. I am not on a soapbox here as a pundit but rather reaching out to others to pull them up here with me.

Cheers,

Bob signature FAIA

even better stuff from Life of an Architect

Dallas CASA Parade of Playhouses 2011
I'd like a McShower please...and supersize it!
Ep 070: Dirty Side to Clean Buildings
What to Get an Architect for Christmas (2013)
The Best Architectural Websites
Surprise! I'm Starting a Residential Studio
My Newest Favorite Old Building - The Galeries de Paléontologie et d'Anatomie Comparée
3 Words: Are. Blogs. Important.
Greene & Greene and Modernism: Complete Perfection
CASA 2010 - The Wrap Up

Share this:

  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window)
  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window)
  • Click to print (Opens in new window)

Filed Under: Life in General, Observations Tagged With: conversations

Search Life of an Architect

Trending on Life of an Architect

Architectural Graphics 101 - Symbols
Architectural Graphics 101 - Window Schedules
Architectural Graphics 101: Finish Schedules
Architectural Graphics 101 - Wall Types
Architectural Graphics 101 - Title Blocks
Architectural Graphics 101: Cover Sheet
Architectural Graphics 101 - Line Weight
Architectural Graphics 101 - Reflected Ceiling Plans
Architectural Graphics 101 - Layers
Tornado Shelters and Safe Rooms

Subscribe to Podcast

Apple PodcastsGoogle PodcastsSpotifyAndroidiHeartRadioby EmailTuneInRSS

Subscribe to our mailing list

* indicates required

Apparel for Architects

T-Shirts for Architects - Bob Borson

Support for Advice or Guidance

Thanks!
Other Amount:
Project Reference or Support for Questions Answered:

My “Serious” Disclaimer

The complimentary advice provided on ‘Life of an Architect’ is based on an abbreviated examination of the minimal facts given, not the typical extensive (and sometimes exhaustive) analysis I conduct when working with my clients. Therefore, anything you read on this site is not a substitute for actually working with me. Following my casual advice is at your own peril … if you want my undivided attention, I would recommend hiring me. Cheers.

Pages

  • Comment Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Architecture Books+
  • about me
  • Questions?
  • F. A. Q.
  • Do you want to be an Architect?
  • Podcast

Life of an Architect | Bob Borson

  • View lifeofanarchitect’s profile on Facebook
  • View bobborson’s profile on Twitter
  • View bobborson’s profile on Instagram
  • View bborson’s profile on LinkedIn

Archives of Awesomeness

Copyright © 2023 Life of an Architect

 

Loading Comments...